Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revisionPrevious revision
Next revision		Previous revision
tasks:zoht [2018/08/10 09:27] – inaritasks:zoht [2021/07/30 13:51] (current) – external edit 127.0.0.1
Line 1: Line 1:
 +<file>
 +Basic Moves:
 +
 +Attack: 7-9 shouldn't come before 10. 
 +<IN: FIXED>
 +
 +Upkeep: I maintain that "default-1" doesn't work well with the time scales we 
 +implemented, since -1 changes it from "a single test" to "right now". And if it 
 +lasts a whole combat, there's no point to extending it to a single test 
 +(already included in the combat). The way we manage time doesn't make this move 
 +ever useful. Also, extending it to default-1 seems strictly inferior to just... 
 +recasting it.
 +My most reasonable reading of this is basically just "recast the spell, but it 
 +doesn't consume your action for the turn."
 +<IN: UPKEEP REMOVED. WILL REPLACE WITH RECAST IF NECESSARY.>
 +
 +
 +Interfere: -2 to the roll or its outcome. (What does -2 to an outcome mean? In 
 +combat I can see it being damage, but I'm not sure I'm seeing where else it 
 +could be used.)
 +
 +Re: Lust: I still think that "including" is ambiguous enough that someone might 
 +get confused. The addition of the damage and the consumption of the lust 
 +debility should be a little more explicit, and I'm confident in that advice so 
 +I'm giving it twice.
 +
 +Service: Can this be used outside of combat? I had a player try to lick 
 +someone's wounds, uh, sensually. I allowed them to take the action but not the 
 +roll. Could just be GM choice, but could be clarified. /shrug
 +
 +</file>
 +
 +
 +
 <file> <file>
 General Notes: General Notes:
Line 6: Line 40:
  
 Replace all " +" and "+ " with "+" a couple times if you concur! Replace all " +" and "+ " with "+" a couple times if you concur!
 +<IN: TODO: SOME ENTRIES FIXED BUT NOT ALL>
  
 Lust is a linked word on the last couple things, but not elsewhere. Do you want  Lust is a linked word on the last couple things, but not elsewhere. Do you want 
Line 22: Line 57:
 6- rolls may include a GM penalty unless otherwise explicitly stated.  6- rolls may include a GM penalty unless otherwise explicitly stated.
 (GM is not obligated to make a hard move, although they are certainly able to.) (GM is not obligated to make a hard move, although they are certainly able to.)
- +<IN: FIXED>
  
 Basic Moves: Basic Moves:
Line 34: Line 68:
 "Either" is different language than PbtA usually uses, and than we use  "Either" is different language than PbtA usually uses, and than we use 
 elsewhere. "Choose one:" is more typical. elsewhere. "Choose one:" is more typical.
 +<IN: FIXED>
  
 Volley: Volley:
Line 41: Line 76:
 Volley's equivalence to Attack in moves makes me nervous as a systems analyst,  Volley's equivalence to Attack in moves makes me nervous as a systems analyst, 
 but I'll have to revisit this later with specific concerns. but I'll have to revisit this later with specific concerns.
 +<IN: FUNCTIONS AS INTENDED :D>
  
 Block: Block:
 Third option: +1 to their next roll should probably be +1 Forward Third option: +1 to their next roll should probably be +1 Forward
 +<IN: FIXED>
  
 Defy Danger: Defy Danger:
Line 50: Line 87:
 Defy Danger can be used when you want to do something that's not covered by  Defy Danger can be used when you want to do something that's not covered by 
 another move, such as pull a lever, or trip an enemy. another move, such as pull a lever, or trip an enemy.
- +<IN: FIXED>
  
 Basic Magic: Basic Magic:
Line 62: Line 98:
 Cast: Cast:
 "enscolled" should be "enscrolled", I think? "enscolled" should be "enscrolled", I think?
 +<IN: FIXED>
  
 Enscrollment: Enscrollment:
Line 70: Line 107:
 Creation Spells: Roll + Charm. Creation Spells: Roll + Charm.
 Destruction/Natural Spells: Roll + Wits. Destruction/Natural Spells: Roll + Wits.
 +<IN: FIXED>
  
 "uses this turn" is kind of vague. "spell is cast this turn" is better. "Spell  "uses this turn" is kind of vague. "spell is cast this turn" is better. "Spell 
Line 75: Line 113:
 Unless I've misinterpreted this and what that means is "your entire turn is  Unless I've misinterpreted this and what that means is "your entire turn is 
 spent enscrolling." spent enscrolling."
 +<IN: FIXED>
  
 Two combat turns or five minutes feels WILDLY disparate. Two combat turns or five minutes feels WILDLY disparate.
 +<IN: FIXED>
  
 "No roll is required" is written right under the outcome of your roll.  "No roll is required" is written right under the outcome of your roll. 
Line 82: Line 122:
 weapon rather than using it? And if so, why is it included in the description  weapon rather than using it? And if so, why is it included in the description 
 of cast? of cast?
 +<IN: FIXED>
  
 Upkeep: Upkeep:
Line 93: Line 134:
 time. There isn't a ton of space between "this lasts one move" and "this lasts  time. There isn't a ton of space between "this lasts one move" and "this lasts 
 all combat," because turns are problematic concepts. all combat," because turns are problematic concepts.
 +<IN: FIXED - UPKEEP REMOVED>
  
  
Line 108: Line 149:
 is dramatic, but feels kind of... eh. Not articulate at this hour, but it feels  is dramatic, but feels kind of... eh. Not articulate at this hour, but it feels 
 like a thing I would abstract away. like a thing I would abstract away.
 +<IN: FIXED?>
  
 Discern Realities: Discern Realities:
Line 121: Line 163:
 but it's often used in very non-social situations by players. I might just move  but it's often used in very non-social situations by players. I might just move 
 this up to Basic Moves. this up to Basic Moves.
 +<FIXED: MOVED TO INTERJECTIONS>
 +
  
 Hustle and Bustle: Hustle and Bustle:
 "You will need to wait or travel" - if it has an "or", it's probably two things. "You will need to wait or travel" - if it has an "or", it's probably two things.
 +<IN: EXPLICIT BINARY OR>
 +
 "You will draw unwanted attention or let others know." - Although this one  "You will draw unwanted attention or let others know." - Although this one 
 seems pretty much fine, since those are the same consequence said differently. seems pretty much fine, since those are the same consequence said differently.
 +<IN: FIXED>
  
 Interfere: Interfere:
Line 141: Line 188:
 reason not to is because you're afraid of having persuasive players talk their  reason not to is because you're afraid of having persuasive players talk their 
 way out of every situation, which is what they're for. way out of every situation, which is what they're for.
 +<IN: FIXED: CHANGED LANGUAGE>
  
 Parley: Parley:
Line 146: Line 194:
 moves, and if there's a distinct difference between them, clarifying it may be  moves, and if there's a distinct difference between them, clarifying it may be 
 worthwhile. worthwhile.
 +<IN: FIXED: DISAMBIGUATED USE CASES>
  
  
Line 175: Line 223:
 things is a crime, it's inconsistent phrasing. We refer to them as attacks  things is a crime, it's inconsistent phrasing. We refer to them as attacks 
 elsewhere. elsewhere.
 +<IN: FIXED-ISH>
  
 Give It: Give It:
Line 192: Line 241:
 (If you have three choices and two of them are "remove a debility," you don't  (If you have three choices and two of them are "remove a debility," you don't 
 actually have three choices.) actually have three choices.)
 +<IN: FIXED>
  
 Tease: Tease:
Line 197: Line 247:
 someone you don't intend to. >D I guess that's a 6- oh well you're at the end  someone you don't intend to. >D I guess that's a 6- oh well you're at the end 
 of the document you just have to read all these words now bla bla bla. of the document you just have to read all these words now bla bla bla.
 +<IN: FIXED: IMPLEMENTED ACCIDENTAL TARGETING>
 </file> </file>